Reformer vs mat Pilates: which one should you start with

Both are Pilates. Both are taught by the same kind of teacher. The difference is what is doing the supporting, and that difference decides who should start where.

The reformer supports you

A reformer is a bed with springs and a moving carriage. The springs can help you or resist you, which means a good teacher can make an exercise easier for one person and harder for the next on the same machine in the same class.

That support is why the reformer suits people starting from scratch, people coming back after injury, and people who find mat work uncomfortable because their back, wrists or knees complain. It is also why it suits people who want to load a movement more heavily than bodyweight allows without lifting weights.

The trade is cost and dependency. Reformer classes cost more to run because the machines cost thousands each and there are a limited number of them, which is why reformer drop-in is £18 and mat is £15.

The mat asks you to support yourself

Mat Pilates is you, a mat and gravity. There is nowhere to hide: if your core cannot hold the position, the position tells you immediately. That directness is the point. Mat work builds the control and awareness that make everything else better, including the reformer.

Mat suits people who already move reasonably well, who want something they can also do at home, and who like the simplicity of it. Hot mat adds heat, which most people experience as easier range of motion and a harder cardiovascular session.

What we would actually recommend

If you have never done Pilates, start with reformer, because the machine teaches you what the movement should feel like before you try to do it unsupported. Two or three reformer sessions gives you a sense of the shapes.

If you have done mat before, or you are reasonably strong and just want to be worked, start with mat and add reformer when you want load.

If you are coming back from injury or pregnancy, reformer, and tell the teacher at booking so the springs are set up properly.

Doing both is the real answer

The people who get the most out of Pilates do both, and not because of upselling. Reformer builds strength and range under support, mat proves you can use it unaided, and the two feed each other week to week.

At our studio that looks like reformer midweek and hot mat at the weekend for a lot of members. Foundations classes sit underneath both if you want the vocabulary before the pace.

More on the two formats: reformer classes and hot mat classes. See the timetable: https://rfrmout.co.uk/bookings/

Book a class

IR

Written by Ismail Randera

Ismail runs RFRM/OUT in Preston, has worked in technology for a decade and has shipped more than fifty products. He writes about what happens in the studio, based on attendance and feedback rather than theory.